Seth Lukas Hynes

Freelance Writer

American Ultra review


American Ultra is an offbeat action comedy with surprising heart.

Absent-minded stoner Mike (Jesse Eisenberg) discovers that he’s actually an elite CIA sleeper agent, and has been targeted for termination.

American Ultra is funny and viscerally exciting, but what stands out about it is its subtle flair with character dynamics.

Mike is a sensitive, apprehensive guy prone to panic attacks, but unleashes deadly, subconscious combat training when threatened. He gradually develops into a better, more confident person by merging the best parts of both sides of himself.

It’s also gratifying to see a male-led action film that features strong female characters. Connie Britton plays Lassetter, a feisty, no-nonsense agent who goes out of her way to guide and protect Mike. And yes, Mike’s primary motivation is to rescue his girlfriend Phoebe (Kristen Stewart, who has finally shaken off the Twilight franchise), but Phoebe is an authoritative figure who can hold her own in a fight.

Mike and Phoebe have a touching relationship of mutual dependency under fire, with a decent twist about Phoebe’s identity.

Mad Max: Fury Road (starring Charlize Theron) takes the cake this year for proactive, awesome female characters, but American Ultra still delivers admirably.

American Ultra satisfies with its goofball humor and brutal, well-choreographed action, but its deep, engaging characters make it rather special.


Mr. Holmes review


Mr. Holmes is like a charming piece of meta-fiction about the world’s greatest detective (no, not Batman).

Long retired and with a failing memory, the great Sherlock Holmes (Sir Ian McKellen) struggles to recall his final case, one which has haunted him for the past 35 years.

There has been a surge in Holmes popularity over the past decade, including the Robert Downey Jr-led action franchise, a present-day reworking starring Benedict Cumberbatch and the House TV series (seriously, Dr. House is Sherlock Holmes as a physician).

But Mr. Holmes offers an ingenious, very self-aware reinterpretation of the character.

McKellen flawlessly conveys the solemn dignity and frailty of a brilliant man fighting against his senility and whose own legacy has overtaken him. Displeased by his old friend Watson’s fictionalizations of their cases, Holmes wishes to restore some truth to his image before he dies by recording his traumatic final case as it really happened – if he can dredge up the details.

Mr. Holmes has sumptuous cinematography and period detail, elegant music and smoothly-executed flashbacks. Holmes’ paternal friendship with his housekeeper’s son Roger (Milo Parker) is very moving and forms another emotional current beyond Holmes’ personal quest.

Mr. Holmes is a poignant, introspective and distinguished drama, and is a great tribute to the classic Sherlock Holmes character.

Room In Rome review

Here is my review of Room In Rome, an unfortunately dull, overwritten and contrived film about a short, passionate relationship between two women in a hotel room.

Follow this link to my review.

The Machine review

Here is my review of The Machine, a compelling, beautifully shot British film very reminiscent of Alex Garland’s Ex Machina.

Follow this link to my review.

The Ideal 1984 Cast

Though 1984 is a harrowing novel, I greatly enjoyed it, and it was fascinating to note how closely (and uncomfortably) it resonates with real history and other, subsequent works of dystopian fiction.

V for Vendetta, Equilibrium, The Matrix, Alphaville, Bioshock, Half-Life 2, the cyberpunk sub-genre; all these and more (including a fair portion of real-world political discourse) would not have existed, or would have been very different, without the groundwork laid by Orwell’s 1984.

I am very interested to see the 1984 film adaptation of 1984, as I love the book, John Hurt and Richard Burton.

But if I were to create a new adaptation of 1984, who would I cast?

After some thought, here are my recommendations.

For Winston Smith, you’d need an actor who isn’t in great shape and who can pull off a dogged everyman persona, but who is also very subtle and sensitive.

Honestly, I’d cast Patton Oswalt as Winston, as he’s a great actor and I’d like to see him in more serious roles.

For Julia, a Party volunteer who is secretly a “rebel from the waist down”, you’d need an actress who is not conventionally attractive but can still be extremely sexy.

Uma Thurman and Charlotte Gainsbourg are too old (for the character; they’re still very attractive women). Shailene Woodley may be a little too young (and rather obvious, after the Divergent series).

I’d ultimately go with Alison Pill as Julia. I personally think Alison Pill is gorgeous, but depending on the role, Pill can either be really beautiful or quite plain, and plainly beautiful, or beautifully plain, is a good way to describe Julia in the novel.

You can also connect Pill to 1984 very easily. Pill played a schoolteacher in Snowpiercer, Bong Joon-ho’s 2013 brilliant darkly satirical science fiction film, alongside John Hurt, who played Winston Smith in the 1984 film.

But since my pick for Winston is substantially older than the character is in the novel, I might instead cast Sally Hawkins as Julia.

For O’Brien: Hugo Weaving, hands down. I love Hugo Weaving, and he’s got a unique combination of warmth, dignity and menace that would be perfect for O’Brien.

Casting Weaving as O’Brien would also be a nifty, ironic role reversal, given that he played the anarchist revolutionary V in V For Vendetta.

Who should play Syme, Winston’s smart colleague who eventually becomes an unperson? I’d cast Welsh actor and comedian Rob Brydon. Brydon is one of my favourite comedians, and his witty, cynical persona would lend itself well to Syme’s intellectual self-satisfaction.

How about Parsons? Johnny Vegas – that was easy.

What about Mr. Charrington, the prole antique dealer who reveals himself as an agent of the Thought Police? You know what – I’d cast Timothy Dalton. Casting a former Bond in such a small part may sound strange, but Dalton could play Charrington as wise and seemingly frail and unassuming, but then really scary once the disguise is dropped.

Finally, who should play Big Brother? Since Big Brother is just a symbol, he doesn’t need to be played by a real person. Given our anxieties about surveillance and privacy in the Internet age, Big Brother’s appearance could be modeled on Mark Zuckerberg or Larry Page (the current Google CEO), or Big Brother could be based on UK Prime Minister David Cameron, as the UK was recently saddled with another term of conservative government.

You’ll have noticed that of my three leads, two are North American – Patton Oswalt is from the US, and Alison Pill is Canadian – and Hugo Weaving is an Aussie.

I don’t think this casting approach is a problem.

1984 is originally set in London, in what used to be the United Kingdom, but Ingsoc and the Party control the British Isles, much of southern Africa, Australia and both Americas. It’s strongly suggested that Party rule has homogenized and wiped away the identity of everywhere under its dominion, so you could set 1984 in New York, Toronto, Johannesburg or even Melbourne, and it wouldn’t feel significantly different.

If you set 1984 in the (former) United States, this could make the story thematically richer. In setting up its rule in the US, the Party could adapt Ingsoc by integrating the socialistic elements of Democrat policy with the curtailing of societal liberties in conservative Republicanism. The two parties are normally diametrically opposed, so combining their methodologies would be a classic application of doublethink.

Call it “Amerisoc”, if you will.

You could draw a parallel between 1984‘s endless war and the War on Terror (or the War on Drugs). Given America’s deep-seated culture of patriotism and national pride, the Party’s control over the US may be weaker than elsewhere, as the people would reject any large retconning of American history. America’s high gun ownership may also provide a further threat to stable Party rule.

Richard III, starring Sir Ian McKellen, did an outstanding job of transplanting the play’s original setting from the Middle Ages to an alternate history fascist 1930s, and the V For Vendetta film was effective in updating the graphic novel’s Thatcher allegory to a more contemporary commentary on George W. Bush’s presidency.

If those earlier revisions worked, then how about 1984?

So, if I could make a 1984 movie, I’d set it in Washington DC (for added poignancy) and cast Patton Oswalt as Winston, Alison Pill or Sally Hawkins as Julia and Hugo Weaving as O’Brien.

I hope you enjoyed my picks and analysis.


1984 (book review)

Here is my review of 1984, an excellent dystopian science fiction novel by George Orwell.

Follow this link to my review.

Princess Blade review

Here is my review of Princess Blade, an exciting and cleverly-written Japanese action movie.

Follow this link to my review.

Business Details

I’m a writer with a BA, Honours degree in Professional and Creative Writing from Deakin University, and have over six years of experience in freelance writing.

I can help you with any of your writing projects, providing one-on-one consultation and advice. My many services include:

  • Copy-writing and proof-reading
  • Business/event advertisements
  • Pamphlets and promotional material
  • Book preparation and editing
  • Memoirs
  • Screenplay pointers

My introductory rate is $30 p/h for first two sessions, and $25 p/h for each subsequent session.

Contact me at:

Reefer Madness review

Here is my review of Reefer Madness, a classic terrible movie that began life as a ridiculous, campy propaganda piece warning against marijuana use.

Follow this link to my review.

Blog at

Up ↑